I started working on Parliament Hill the week after 9/11. I was starting a new job in the one of the most heated environments in the country at the time and to say that anxiety lurked in every corner was certainly a bit of an understatement. Tension and sadness was every where. No one knew what to make of everything that had just happened and our world just looked different.
Being a political assistant, one of the components of my job was to take all of the constituent calls coming in for the Member of Parliament and doing so with an unbiased opinion or political position. My job was to sit in the one of the most emotional charged places while remaining in a nonpartisan position.
I know that this is going to come off sounding somewhat ridiculous for someone that spent nearly four years walking the halls of Parliament Hill…but I don’t actually care much for politics! While I understand, respect and appreciate its role, I also believe that our country holds itself to a certain societal standard that can withstand even the most tumultuous of political hurricanes.
This “at-an-arm’s-length-from-the-political-stratosphere” belief system does have a few exceptions though…and war is one of them…
I have a hard time with war. I have a hard time understanding war and I have a hard time believing in war. I know that there are reasons that are beyond my comprehension because as I’ve mentioned here before, history is always written by the winners; those who are left standing and can tell the story…usually while leaving the other side out. So I do understand that there are reasons beyond what I can see; rights, safety, responsibility to help those who can’t necessarily help themselves. But no matter how much I rationalize this in my head…all I can think about is the loss; the loss of innocence, the loss of life, the loss of decency. There is so much extraordinary loss…and that, in turn, becomes the other side of the story.
The week that I started my new job was that the same week that our Prime Minister at the time, Mr. Jean Chretien, declared that Canada would not be joining President Bush’s War on Terrorism. I’ve always been a big fan of Mr. Chretien but I’ve never been as proud of him as I was on that day!
Allow me to apologize now if I happen to offend of my U.S. readers (or Canadian readers for that matter) but I just need to say that for whatever impact President Bush may have had on my views regarding war, he lost me entirely when he stated that “you’re either with us or you’re against us”. No matter how strong the argument may be or how tragic the events leading up it; war is simply not black or white.
I can only speak for myself when I say that such a statement made me feel bullied. It made me feel like some big kid at school was trying to back me into a corner and threatening to steal my lunch money every day if I didn’t join the after school fight that was about to happen in the playground. And I’m not trying to imply that this war was or is a childish battle of kids fighting over sand in sandbox…I’m just trying to say that ultimatums aren’t often very effective…even when you are the biggest kid in school.
So allow me to backtrack once again to 2001, the week following Mr. Chretien’s statement. I was being riddled with phone calls in the office from constituents wanting to share their views regarding his decision. Some were angry, some were happy and others just sat on the phone and cried. It was a hard week. That Friday afternoon, around 4:15pm, a gentleman called to express his outrage at Mr. Chretien’s decision and how he should be forced to step down as Prime Minister because he’d become a disgrace to our country.
I had been taking in people’s emotions for two weeks now and I had been forced to politely sit there responding as though I was one of the few that had somehow been immunized from the effects of what was going on around me. This could only go on for so long. So after listening to him literally yell at me on the phone for twenty minutes, the nonpartisan, unbiased side of me began to fade away and the well bred debater in me began to emerge. We began to chat for a little while…we began to ask questions. We stopped being a constituent and a political office and started being two people facing the prospect of war. I asked him if he had any children…he said yes; a son and a daughter. I asked him if either of them were in the military; he said no. I asked him if he would still support this war to the same degree if either of them were going to be the ones to fight it; he was silent…and he was appalled.
I had apparently just flown the emotional equivalent of a terrorist piloted plane into his argument and now a different kind of war had begun.
He just hung up on me. No other words. No retaliation. He was just gone.
I didn’t ask him these questions to be rude or disrespectful; I asked them because I felt that it was too easy to see this battle as nothing more than a political statement when it is in fact a war that someone has to fight. And that someone might be somebody’s brother or sister; mother or father; wife or husband…but at the very least, that someone is always somebody’s child. And not all of those children are going to come home.
It’s easier to support a war when you know that you won’t be the one receiving a phone call in the middle of the night or holding the flag once draped over a casket. But that’s what war really is; when you peel away all of the political agendas, media frenzies, economic impacts and cloaks of good intention…you have somebody’s child. And that’s always what the real question should be; would you be willing to sacrifice your child to this cause…because that’s very well what you may end up doing?
I think that this is as good a time as any to mention that while I may not support the need to send people to war, I do recognize the choice that many people have made on their own to do so and I support their efforts in the midst of it. But even that hasn’t come without its own line of questioning. I fully acknowledge that past sacrifices were made for our present freedoms but I guess my ideals for the world just leave me in a position of wishing that we never had to sacrifice anyone to begin with. So it seems though, there will always be fights to be fought and battles to be won and now it’s our turn to bear the potential brunt of that sacrifice.
My brother-in-law was shipped off to Afghanistan on Monday to spend nine months fighting in a place that keeps sending our men and women home in wooden boxes. He’s going to fly our soldiers around because they keep getting killed by roadside bombs. And while I’m beyond proud of him for what he’s willing to do for his country, I don’t enjoy listening to my six year niece on the phone talking about how her daddy has to go away for a long time; or watching my sister-in-law become a single parent for close to a year; or hearing his mother’s teary-eyed account of saying goodbye to her oldest son; or holding my breath every time the news comes on. I don’t enjoy experiencing first hand what it’s like when somebody’s child goes to war because as I once heard said a long time ago; War is not about who’s right…it’s about who’s left.
Come home soon Jeff…and come home safely…
